Pagdi System Building Rentor Is Defaulting

Asked in Real estate

  • S S

    Mumbai

Expert's Answers(4)

  • Nischal N

    Bengaluru Urban, Karnataka
     

    my opinion is that the legal heirs of A have grounds to seek recovery of possession of the property, along with appropriate monetary relief, subject to the documents and the nature of B's occupation. Since the property was originally purchased by A from B, and B continued to occupy the premises even after execution of the conveyance, the first issue that needs to be examined is the legal basis on which B continued in possession. In my view, merely executing a sale deed in favour of A does not automatically mean that B has lost every right to occupy the premises, particularly when the property is governed by the Pagdi system. It is necessary to examine whether B continued as a protected tenant, whether there was any separate understanding permitting B to remain in possession, or whether B was required to hand over vacant possession under the terms of the sale deed. This distinction will play an important role in deciding the appropriate legal remedy. With regard to the unpaid rent for the last 22 years, the legal heirs may not be able to recover the entire arrears because of the law of limitation. Under Article 52 of the Limitation Act, 1963, a claim for recovery of arrears of rent is generally subject to a limitation period of three years from the date on which each instalment becomes due. Therefore, the claim for rent should be examined carefully, including whether there are any acknowledgments of liability or other circumstances affecting limitation. If B is legally established to be a tenant, the provisions of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999, particularly Sections 15 and 16, will have to be considered. The landlord cannot simply seek eviction without establishing a legally recognised ground and following the prescribed procedure. If there is a case of non-payment of rent, the statutory demand notice and other requirements under Section 15 must be complied with before proceeding with eviction. Since the matter is already pending before the High Court, I would suggest taking appropriate steps for early disposal rather than unnecessarily initiating parallel proceedings. An application for early hearing and expeditious disposal can be considered, bringing to the Court's attention the long pendency of the matter, repeated non-appearance of the respondents, if supported by the order sheets, and the continuing hardship suffered by the legal heirs. If the respondents have been duly served but are repeatedly absent, the Court can also be requested to

    October 30, 2026
  • Harsh Vardhan

    Central Delhi, Delhi
     

    Please contact me on my phone number 7033188525

    October 29, 2026
  • Advocate J.N. Dwivedi

    Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh
      3 Client Ratings

    Please contact on my phone number 9554932027

    October 23, 2026
  • Komal Tyagi Advocate

    New Delhi, Delhi
      2 Client Ratings

    Kindly contact us for more details. +919667660556

    October 23, 2026